Sub Club sunk

I am old enough to have observed my children’s tastes swing markedly over the years from McDonald's to Subway. While Maccas seems stuck in a no-man's-land between cringing promotion of its healthier-than-healthy options while still trying to satisfy the basic urges of the chip-and-burger brigade, Subway has successfully ridden the public wave of better eating.

Subway’s offering is straightforward and uncomplicated. While none of its franchisees or their staff has attended a Subway equivalent of Hamburger University, it seems to offer reasonably healthy food at reasonable prices with reasonable service usually thrown in.

But one change has been the demise of Subway’s loyalty program, Sub Club. It was long lasting, fairly simple to execute and rated about a three out of five stars for customers. In classic green stamps fashion, you were handed a number of coupons or stamps based on what you’d bought, affixed them to your Sub Club card, then redeemed when you’d filled up the card. Fairly simple mechanism.

Where Subway lost points was that it wasn't quite simple enough. While the stamp-earning formula was fairly straightforward (one stamp for a "six-inch", two for a "foot-long"), it was more confusing how the “burn” end worked out. I always had to remind myself from the fine print on the card what I really would get out of it. And it was - collect 8 stamps (one full card), then if I buy "one medium fountain beverage", I’d get a free six-inch sub for nothing. Alternatively, I could collect 16 stamps and get a free foot-long sub if I purchased a fountain drink.

With loyalty programs it matters less if I don’t perfectly understand the "earn" rate, but if the “business end” is hard to understand – the “what’s-in-it-for-me” bit, then that’s more of a problem. Also, if it has too many hurdles – in this case the mandatory drink purchase - then it can start to lose gloss.

Nevertheless, with Subway’s Sub Club, I soldiered on. With all my family members happy to frequent Subway, we racked up he stamps rather quickly, and I got used to the way the deal worked. I was even handed stamps at a Subway in London, fully redeemable in Warrigal Road, Ashburton!

But Subway wasn't enjoying the deal as much as I was, and last year announced the end of the party. No more Sub Club.

Now, loyalty programs are hard to start up, but they’re a darn sight harder to stop. It’s a bit like the boss handing out the turkey at Christmas – whatever goodwill he or she gained in year 1 is more than wiped out when he or she forgets or decides against it in year “n”.

Subway didn’t fare too badly. It gave customers plenty of notice about when the stamps would no longer be handed out; it gave them plenty of time to cash in their chips and then when it was all over it actually handed out cash discounts for any cards not filled up – a 100% redemption rate play at the end of the promotion. Hard to fault that. The only thing that irked was their mixed messages about why they were pulling up stumps. The notice in-store stated that the Club meant that only some customers, not others, were getting the goodies, so it was somehow inequitable. Purlease! Try extending that principle elsewhere in society! The reason more widely promoted, even by Subway, was that the opportunities for fraud, no doubt coupled with general moral decay was pushing up the share of chancers and sheisters getting unscheduled access to treats. When Sub Club stamps became widely available on eBay, Subway's owners were not overly impressed. Even worse was the talk of staff theft of the stamps, evidenced by entire rolls of stamps appearing online! So maybe the demise was inevitable.

The bit of data I don’t have regards the residual impact of stopping the loyalty program. Of course there’s no public data available on that. And it would be hard for the Subway bean counters to work that out as well. Because ultimately loyalty programs only offer the cream on top. The world’s most effective loyalty program is only going to add a marginal benefit to the bottom line. Could be worth millions if you’re big enough, but not so easy to read off a 3-D column chart or a low-angled, tilted, chunk-out pie chart!

In some countries, a new Subway loyalty card has sprung up. But for us in the rest of the Subway world, we're missing our stamps. Would Subway be regretting its move? What do you think?

Forgot to show my card and save

Show Your Card & Save is the benefit program adopted by Australian Auto Clubs over the last few years, apparently lifted from a scheme set up in the US in 1993.

I was intrigued by the long list of benefits on offer when it was first spruiked by RACV, the automobile club to which I belong. Certainly in terms of volume it seems to beat any similar offering I've seen.

And yet there is something intrinsically frustrating about this benefit program. And that is, I just can’t remember who the benefit providers are. The only one I've been able to commit to memory is Rebel Sport, 5% discount there, quite useful. But of all the rest, I just can’t recall. At one stage I kept the page out of the RACV mag that has the list of participants, but it’s not as if I’m going to carry it with me.

Yet here’s the rub. You can bet that nearly all the benefit providers won’t be putting up in lights that they’re part of the Show Your Card & Save program. After all, what’s in it for them, once you're in the store? They’d be hoping that before I set out to purchase an item, I’d check out the list and head their way, but I'm afraid it’s just not going to happen that way. And they’re not about to ask me at the check-out if I'm an RACV member – it would be akin to them asking me “how would you like to claim 5% of my margin that you weren’t really expecting as a discount?”

So I see it as a bit of a loyalty program with your hands tied behind your back. For the participating retailer, they’ll be handing out the occasional discount, but it’s hard to see members seeking them out, if like me they suffer from the can’t-remember-who’s-in-it problem. For an RACV member like me, there’s the frustration of finding out some time later that I had foregone a discount, if only I’d remembered to show my card and saved. And what’s in it for RACV? Well, maybe they’re the winner in all of this – they get to paint the picture to members that there’s a world of discounts waiting for them. Maybe only the astute (or anal) member will delve deep into the list and find out that some of the participants are giants of commerce like Wombat Gully Plant Farm or Wooling Hill Memorial Garden Estate.

Of course, benefit programs aren’t solely the domain of auto clubs. The Virgin Money credit card, in its tip-our-nose-at-those-nasty-banks mode, touts its Mates Rates deal as some über-offer to trump the standard credit card reward programs. Behind the veneer is a slightly underwhelming collection of offers. And only slightly more distant cousins are the likes of the well-worn Presidential Card, Entertainment Book, and a newer entrant - the My Rewards program.

My Rewards seems to have had some recent success in offering itself as a kind of club plug-in, a small something that might make a point of difference in seeking subscribers to a particular service. Sturt Football Club, the SANFL team for which I retain a deal of affection, offers it with every membership pack, while the other day Gary & Warren Smith offered it to me as a point of difference among Honda dealers. Again, perhaps helpful for the entity offering it to clinch a sale, but I fear of marginal utility to the unsuspecting consumer. Perhaps just another chance to forget to show my card and save?