But if that's a sin in loyalty land, I reckon an even greater one is attempting to provide a personalised, targeted communication and failing miserably in the execution. And without naming names, one of Australia's most prominent loyalty programs has managed to do that with an email stream in recent months.
A couple of days back I received my "exclusive January offers" promoting the program's affiliates. (Never mind it was received on the last day of January, I'm assuming the offers didn't expire that day). But tellingly the email is headed up "my range of local rewards". And that's where the problem really begins, since each time I have received these emails over the past ten months, they are full of retailers that are anywhere but "local" to me. Some examples:
- Hair salon in Wantirna, 24 kilometres away
- Coffee in Doncaster, 12 kilometres away
- Liquor from Fitzroy North, 16 kilometres away
- Jewellery in Frankston, 50 kilometres away
- Travel agent in Ringwood, 22 kilometres away
- Fruit from Cheltenham, 12 kilometres away
A couple of extra pointers here - it's not as if the above examples are the exceptions among a range of other truly local shopping options; these anything-but-local offerings form the majority. Also, you'll note that none of them are for specialised goods or services that warrant long travel to hunt down. A hairdresser can be found in suburban Melbourne without necessitating a 24 km trip. Fruit can also be quite handy.
However, the most disappointing aspect is this - they know from my purchase behaviour where I DO shop - and it's not in any of the suburbs listed above.
To be fair, the program in question often does a good job in using transaction data, even at a product level, to make relevant offers. In the particular case of the program affiliates, I suspect that there may be other commercial factors that get in the way. But despite ten months for them to get this right, targeting excellence, like these "offers", seems yet some distance away.